DMARC Record Checker vs MXToolbox

MXToolbox is a well-known name in email diagnostics. They've been around for years and offer a wide range of network and email tools. Here's how we compare for DMARC checking and monitoring.

Quick Comparison

Different Tools, Different Focus

MXToolbox is a Swiss Army knife for network and email diagnostics:

• DMARC, SPF, DKIM lookups
• MX record checking
• Blacklist monitoring
• DNS diagnostics
• SMTP testing
• And much more

We focus specifically on email authentication:

• DMARC checking and monitoring
• SPF, DKIM, MX monitoring
• Daily automated checks
• Simple alerts when things break

When to Choose MXToolbox

MXToolbox makes sense if you need:

Broad diagnostics: You troubleshoot various email and network issues regularly, not just authentication.

One-off checks: You occasionally need to look up DNS records or test SMTP connections.

Multiple tool types: DMARC is just one of many things you check. You also need blacklist monitoring, DNS propagation checks, etc.

Ad-hoc usage: You don't need continuous monitoring, just occasional diagnostics.

When to Choose Us

Our approach works better if you need:

Focused monitoring: You want ongoing monitoring specifically for email authentication records.

Simpler experience: You don't need 50 different tools. You need to know if your email authentication is working.

Bundled monitoring: SPF, DKIM, DMARC, and MX all monitored together, daily, with alerts.

Flat pricing: One price for unlimited domains. No per-check or per-domain fees.

Pricing Comparison

MXToolbox pricing (check their site for current):

• Free: Limited lookups per day
• Delivery Center: Starts around $100/month
• Various plans with different feature sets

Email Deliverability Suite:

• Free tier: Up to 3 domains
• Pro: $39/month for unlimited domains
• All email authentication records included

For dedicated email authentication monitoring, our pricing is typically lower.

Feature Comparison

Lookups

Both offer free DMARC lookups. MXToolbox has more tool variety (SMTP, DNS propagation, etc.). We focus on email authentication.

Monitoring

MXToolbox Delivery Center: Comprehensive email monitoring including blacklist, DMARC reports, and more.

Email Deliverability Suite: Focused on DNS record monitoring with daily checks and change alerts.

User Experience

MXToolbox: Many tools, many options. Powerful but can be overwhelming.

Us: Simple dashboard focused on email authentication status. Is it working? Yes/no. Did something change? Here's what.

Blacklist Monitoring

MXToolbox: Blacklist checking is a core feature.

We have a dedicated blacklist checker: emailblacklistchecker.com, also part of the Email Deliverability Suite.

Use Case: Ad-Hoc Checking

If you occasionally need to check a DMARC record or troubleshoot an email issue, both tools work well for free lookups.

MXToolbox advantage: More tool variety for different diagnostic needs.

Our advantage: Cleaner, focused interface for authentication specifically.

Use Case: Ongoing Monitoring

If you need continuous monitoring of email authentication:

MXToolbox Delivery Center: Comprehensive but more expensive. Good if you need all their features.

Email Deliverability Suite: Focused on the records that matter for email authentication. Simpler and more affordable.

Use Case: Multi-Domain Management

For agencies, MSPs, or anyone managing multiple domains:

MXToolbox: Domain-by-domain checking. Monitoring requires paid plans.

Us: Portfolio-wide view of all domains. $39/month covers unlimited domains.

The Bottom Line

Choose MXToolbox if:

• You need various network and email diagnostic tools
• DMARC is just one of many things you check
• You want occasional ad-hoc lookups
• You need their specific features (SMTP testing, etc.)

Choose Email Deliverability Suite if:

• You want focused email authentication monitoring
• You prefer simpler, cleaner tools
• Flat pricing for unlimited domains matters
• You want daily monitoring with alerts

MXToolbox is a great general-purpose toolkit. We're a focused solution for email authentication monitoring.

Try Our Free DMARC Checker

Check your domain's DMARC status instantly. Clean interface, no clutter.